Stronghold: Definitive Edition logo

Stronghold: Definitive Edition Review – A Castle-Building Legend Reborn

Today, we take a detailed delve into a stronghold of nostalgia—Stronghold: Definitive Edition, a remastered version of the quintessential medieval RTS, which after two decades, still stands tall, proclaiming its legacy with a banner of refreshed graphics and contemporary features.

Stronghold by FireFly Studios first made its appearance in 2001, quickly becoming a haven for strategy enthusiasts. Through its deft blend of city-building and RTS warfare, it carved a unique niche, striking a harmonious balance between economic management and the brutal, unyielding nature of medieval combat. Fast-forward to 2023, and we are presented with its Definitive Edition, a testament to its enduring appeal.

image 2023 11 10T023310.456

The Definitive Edition aims to cater to a dual audience—those who have fond memories of marshaling troops against the backdrop of medieval England and novices to the series, seeking a new, yet classic, experience. At a modest price of $14.99 on Steam, it promises much but do the stone walls of this fortress still hold firm against the winds of time?

Technical and Visual Overhaul

Remarkably, the game achieves a momentous stride in the realm of visuals. The transition to 4K support—accompanied by an overhauled user interface and high-resolution textures—tethers the game aptly to modern expectations without undermining its original aesthetic that we’ve come to cherish. Its commitment to maintaining the old-world charm, coupled with the vibrancy of detailed environments, casts a spell of immersion potent enough to transport us back two decades.

Performance Enhancements

Performance-wise, the game navigates the line of modernization with tactical finesse. The integration with Steamworks introduces a newfound fluidity in matchmaking and community interactions, which is a welcoming feature given the game’s age. Other technical improvements come as a sigh of relief for those who may recall the technical hiccups of the original game—improved pathfinding, increased unit count, and support for ultrawide monitors have made the game substantially more accessible and enjoyable.

Bugs and Compatibility Issues

image 2023 11 10T023318.737

Like a suit of armor showing signs of rust, there are a few minor bugs that mar the otherwise polished surface. While these issues are not game-breaking, the kinks concerning multiplayer game loading are particularly disconcerting for those who thrive on the game’s competitive aspects. FireFly Studios have committed to addressing these problems, so it is a waiting game to see how quickly these issues can be ironed out.

Campaign and Challenging Gameplay

Stronghold: Definitive Edition introduces a robust new campaign featuring 14 missions, which are intricately woven into the original’s narrative fabric. The challenges therein are befitting for veterans, and equally enthralling for newcomers who embark on their first sortie into this medieval saga.

However, the narrative feel does not dazzle as much as the sieges and battles themselves. While veterans may find an element of monotony in revisiting age-old adversaries, the missions do facilitate a battleground to flaunt their strategic prowess. For some, the Castle Trail—with its 10 historical castle missions—may swing as the saving grace, allowing predetermined setups that test the ability to strategize effectively under limitations.

Multiplayer Lament and the Workshop

The Steam integration is, without doubt, the shield-bearer of the game’s multiplayer experience. The combination of Steam’s robust framework and the game’s enduring gameplay forms a coalition fit for king and country. The inclusion of Workshop support heralds a banquet of custom scenarios and maps, bringing the community’s creativity to the forefront.

Yet, the multiplayer skirmishes are devoid of co-op matches, and the absence of alternative modes leaves the experience feeling underdeveloped. The PvP-centric battles, though gripping, may not suffice for those with a penchant for collaborative gameplay.

User-Friendly Features and Quality of Life Improvements

It’s refreshing to see that the game’s user interface and control systems have been paid heed, recognizing the evolutions in player expectations. The addition of switchable controls and mouse wheel camera zoom imbues the gameplay with a touch of modernity that is intuitive, yet doesn’t betray the original’s spirit. These adjustments smoothly ease the player into a comfort zone so that they can focus on the empire at hand.

A Word on Replayability and Accessibility

image 2023 11 10T023302.085

Despite its varied modes of play, the simplicity and predictability of the game’s systems could potentially stifle long-term play. Once the learning curve plateaus, the game may lose its initial hypnotic pull. However, this simplicity can be a boon for those looking to dive into a game that isn’t encumbered with overwhelming mechanics—weaving in an element of accessibility that contemporary RTS titles may at times overlook.

The Crossroads – A Matter of Preference

This remastered iteration of Stronghold will find its most ardent admirers among those with a reverence for the original. However, is it equipped with enough incentives to entrap the younger generation? The updated experience is engaging, yet it struggles to fully encapsulate the depth and gameplay advancements that later titles have introduced into the RTS genre. The stickler for the sophistication of modern games may find Stronghold’s quaint charm overshadowed by its dated core design.

Reflections on Price and Value

At $14.99, the Definitive Edition presents itself as an economical excursion into nostalgia for the set who yearn for a remembrance of gaming’s past triumphs. Comparatively, for those who are fresh to the ramparts of Stronghold, the value lies in experiencing a pivotal turning point in RTS history, wrapped neatly within an affordable package.

Towards the Future

FireFly Studios’ roadmap suggests that more content is destined to join the fray, hinting that the tapestry of Stronghold is yet to be fully unfurled. Fans have raised their banners in hopes of skirmish modes and improved AI. If the studio accedes to these clamors, we might witness the resurgence of a behemoth capable of standing its ground amidst the contemporary gaming citadel.

Verdict – A Castle Worth the Siege?

Stronghold: Definitive Edition is a celebration of a timeless RTS. It doesn’t stand as a reinvention, but rather, as an affirmation of the longevity and success of its forebear. It exemplifies how a classic can be invigorated with a judicious mix of restraint and innovation, hitting the right notes for an audience who relishes strategy gaming with a touch of historical flavor.

Rating: 8/10

Loyal to its origins, and fortified with the tools of today’s technological arsenal, the Definitive Edition beckons to our nostalgic selves. It’s a castle of memories worth visiting, if not for the new embellishments, then for the simple joy of catapulting a diseased cow over battlements one more time. The game extends an invitation—a gauntlet thrown at our feet, daring us to step into the bailey of our gaming past and rise once again as the lord of our besieged empire. Should you answer the call to arms? The gates are open, and the stronghold endures.

About the author

Tom Henry

I worked as a PM in video games, now I'm trying some new things.

Add Comment

Click here to post a comment